13
Keynote 3 by the numbers: Part 1. First Impressions
Posted by | Posted in Reviews | Posted on 01-13-2006
The new Keynote that ships as a part of iWork ’06 is quite an impressive upgrade. While an argument could be made that Keynote 2 was bug fixes and refinements for Keynote 1, Keynote 3 polishes up what we liked about Keynote 2 and added features to just about every aspect of the program. Since glossing over these in one article would be a disservice to our readers, we’ve decided to concentrate on one aspect at a time (so we don’t miss anything!). We begin with an examination of what differences a user is likely to notice immediately when simply browsing the menus.
First thing you’ll notice is that iWork ’06 does NOT overwrite iWork ’05. It creates a new folder labeled iWork ’06 and leaves the other alone. Because of this, if you’ve placed any iWork apps in your dock, you’ll need to place the new versions there manually. After that, you may feel a strong urge to delete the iWork folder. However, I would urge you to keep it around for a month or so. If you need to, set an iCal alarm to remind you to remove it later if you need the space. But, until the user community has had the opportunity to go over it and has given it the “Upgrade Bill of Health” you should probably keep the old version around as a backup (if presenting is your business I KNOW I don’t have to tell YOU this, right?) Also, as with all Apple applications PLEASE leave these applications in the folder into which they are installed.
Upon opening the app, you’re presented with a theme selection screen. There you’ll find a number of new themes that include:
Modern Portfolio and Formal which adopts the clean polished look of Keynote Pro’s themes,
Leather Book and Classic Silk, both good looking textures of their namesakes with the standard theme layout,
and White Corners and Vintage which harken back to the photo book look of MyKeynoteThemes.
Another new theme is Black, which is basically the White theme in reverse. Many of us accustomed to working with Keynote have been manually making changes to our presentations to set the background color of the White theme to black then adjusting the text color, but it’s nice to see it as an addition. Keynote also adds to the 800×600 and 1024×768 slide sizes by adding 1280×720, 1680×1050, 1920×1080 to some select themes (White, Black, Gradient, Modern Portfolio, and White Corners). Another thing you’ll notice is that only Apple’s theme preview images have white borders now. It’s a small point but now themes from some of the theme makers have black lines on the left and right making them just look… different. While on the subject of themes, these new themes are NOT available to Keynote 2. What this means from a theme creation/management perspective remains to be seen.
Taking a trip through the menus shows what you’ve come to know from Keynote for Keynote, File, and Edit. Hopefully, “Edit LinkBack Item” will find it’s way happily back into my Edit menu once the plugin is updated for Keynote 3 and for those wondering about “Special Characters…” under the Edit menu, yes Bank Gothic is still a broken font. The Insert menu is the first to see significant change. It’s been reworked to be more streamlined so that all of the Shapes are now under a submenu. The built in shapes have also increased in number to include a Star, Polygon and “Draw a Shape” which is easy speak for Bezier curves. Both the Star and Polygons are variable in that you are presented with a popup interface to control the number of points and sides respectively. Draw a Shape allows you to create your own shapes within Keynote limited only by your artistic ability. There’s also a nifty new feature that lets you insert comments complete with their own little sticky note (looks like the one in Dashboard). Just remember that if you want to click and move them, only the area along the top and bottom is grabbable, not the sides.
The Slide menu sees no changes while the Format menu has some interesting items that hint at new features. First up is Format -> Table -> Fill Cells which allows you to select a table cell and fill every cell you select to the right and down with the selected cell’s data. Next is Chart which, under Chart Type includes not only a scatter plot, but a collection of new 3D charts too, from 3D columns, to 3D lines to 3D pies, 3D versions of charts you know and love. With the new Shape menu under Format comes options to Sharpen or Smooth them but only after either creating your own shape within Keynote or selecting a shape and choosing Make Editable. Another new command under Shape is Reset Text and Object Handles. One of the most impressive new features of Keynote is the ability to mask an image with a shape using the Mask with Shape command that we’ll go over in depth later.
Moving along, we find the simple elegance of the Arrange menu has been left untouched between versions while View offers some pleasant surprises. Now, we have the ability to Rehearse Slideshows without the need for a second monitor. Also new is a Light Table view that allows another way to rearrange your slides, Show Notes is renamed Show Presenter Notes, there’s an option to Hide Comments (remember the sticky notes?), and another to Show Adjust Image which brings another popup interface onto the screen to allow basic adjustments to your imported images.
Skipping past the Window menu, you’ll find the Help menu and again Apple has supplied us with an iWork Tour specifically highlighting the special features of iWork ’06.
And there you have it, a faster than fast introduction to the new Keynote. Even though the above changes are cool, that’s nothing compared to what we’ll be examining in the coming weeks when we begin to dig even deeper into what iWork’s better half has to offer. Next up, we’re going to inspect the inspectors!
thanks, keep it coming.
Thanks for the in depth review, Brian. Look forward to seeing some more.
TXs, very interesting
Actually, make SURE you watch the names under the title…I’m not the only one working on this site, and I wouldn’t want Ken to get his feelings hurt
Looks like I need to add the Author tag to the STORY page as it seems to only be showing up on the front page.
Very informative! I spent last night just exploring the Keynote 3. I am quite happy with this update as well as new version of Pages.
I scrambled to get a copy of iWork’06 as fast as I could so I could investigate “what’s new,” too. Here are a few wee details.
1. Keynote 2 weighed in at about 200MB; Keynote 3 is over 1.0GB! Clear some space off your overburdened hard drive, Keynoters. (The old iWork app folder was 600MB; iWork’06 app folder is 1.85GB.)
2. You can now scale grouped objects! O happy day. For me, that and Béziers make it worth the price of admission. Well, that and the Reflection transition that I can add to the list of transitions to use so people know I’m cooler than a PPT user.
3. After I installed iWork’06; I update-saved a Keynote file. When I tried to reopen it, Keynote 3.0.0 (build 1) unexpectedly crashed! Yikes. Of course, Keynote 2 could no longer open it, since it was now a Keynote 3 file. I went back; repaired permissions on the volume, restarted, and all appears to be well.
Bank Gothic fix. In Keynote 3, under preferences, general, you can select/deselect use smart quotes. If you deselect use smart quotes and THEN type using Bank Gothic, quotes ” ” will appear.
Justin,
Yes, you can do that as a workaround, but you shouldn’t have to disable a function in order to use a font. As has been posted here
http://keynotethemepark.com/k2/k2.html
Bitstream has confirmed that the font is corrupt and it looks like it still will be until some future update.
QTVR IN KEYNOTE?
Incredibly, Keynote has not been able to handle QTVR files. PowerPoint does. This inability of Keynote has been an annoyance for me, and seems like a major gaffe on Apple’s part. Will QTVR work in Keynote 3?
LINKING TO SLIDES WITHIN A PRESENTATION
Let’s say you’re on slide 16 of a presentation, and want to move to another Keynote file. No problem — you can hyperlink there.
But now you want to return to slide 17 in your original presentation. In Keynote, no can do. (You CAN do this in PowerPoint).
Has Apple fixed this glitch in Keynote 3?
I don’t think you can hyperlink to a slide in a different file.
Does the installation of Keynote 3 remove any themes as the installation of Keynote 2 did? (If I remember right it was Leatherbook and something else that were left out of Keynote 3)
Current issues I am having with Keynote 2 is that it will not open on my new G5 and I sent my code to apple tech support and stumped them. Meanwhile I have my entire class programed in Keynote 2 and had to export to PPP to fine tune my programs. When exported, all the transitions had been disrupted.
Has the exporting to PPP feature been improved in 3?
I plan on purchasing Keynote 3 but not if its not backwards compatible with Keynote 2. Why such the forward thinking on apples part?
How about schools that cannot afford every upgrade for 200 computers? This in my mind is a HUGE mistake on apples part. Consider backwards compatible.
Cubert,
No, for me, I’ve got all of Keynote 2 and 3 available, with the new themes only available in Keynote 3.
Rich,
There’s actually an option to export as iWork ’05.
What happened to the grid transition? It was one of the best! What were they thinking getting rid of it?
All of the old effects are still there, you just have to turn them on in the prefs.
Are we sure that we are going to get a Linkback plugin for this version????
Also, there is an interesting reflection button in the graphic panel (I am not talking about the transition) that, however, is always disabled….
The reflection button is for images only, not objects. It creates an instant reflection of your image below it, and lets you adjust the amount of darkness on the reflection.
No idea on the linkback, but I’d bet we’ll see it before too long.
Thanks!
Why they did not allow the reflection for objects too?
I guess that would have been a simple but nice extension….
If you have Illustrator or Photoshop, you can design AI or PNG files with transparency and use reflection on them. Have fun designing your own icons and objects!
Gian,
Another trick to making your objects into images (for reflection) is to copy, go to Preview, then choose New from Clipboard. Copy this and paste back into Keynote and it’ll be an image that looks just like the text it’s replacing.
I am converting my class lecture files from PowerPoint to Keynote 3. One problem I find often is increase in file size. Sometimes a 3-4 MB PPT file becomes 30 MB in Keynote. Does anyone have an explanation and actually cure for this?
Does Keynote 3 have the ability to embed music in a particular slide, have it only play for X number of slides, and continue the rest of the presentation without the music (as PPT does)? I really miss that capability in Keynote 2!
No, Keynote doesn’t have that function yet. You either have music on a slide or music as a background over all slides, but not from slide to slide.
Im facing a similar problem. I’d like to link up several audio files in one slide and be able to select any one of them in the presentation. I found a solution (may be quick and dirty): I placed several objects (circles, say) on one slide, each object hyperlinked to an empty slide at the end. I embed audio into the empty file at the end. This seems to work but still it is not as good as what powerpoint would give. I’d appreciate better solutions.